LIMA
With God's help
עברית

Coulomb's Law and Superposition

Imagine that you are standing in the middle of a plaza, and several friends are trying to pull or push you with invisible ropes. If two strong friends pull you with exactly the same force but in completely opposite directions, you will stay in place, because the forces will cancel each other out completely. But if several friends stand at different angles, you will have to weigh the direction and strength of each pull separately to know where exactly you will fly off in the end. Each friend acts independently, but your motion is the combined result of all of them together - and this is exactly the way electric charges affect one another in space.

The theory in brief

The electric force acting between two point charges is described in physics by Coulomb's law: \[\vec{F} = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0}\frac{q_1 q_2}{r^2}\hat{r}.\] This equation states that the magnitude of the force is directly proportional to the product of the charges, and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them, where the direction \((\hat{r})\) is set by the signs of the charges (like charges repel, opposite charges attract).

Since in nature charges usually do not act in single pairs, we rely on the superposition principle. This principle states that the total force acting on a charge is the vector sum of all the forces exerted on it by each of the other charges separately: \[\vec{F}_{total} = \sum \vec{F}_i.\] To solve such a system in two dimensions, we resolve each force vector into its \(x\) and \(y\) components. Then, the magnitude of the resultant force is calculated with the Pythagorean theorem: \[\left|\vec{F}_{total}\right| = \sqrt{F_x^2 + F_y^2},\] and its direction (the angle) is found with the tangent function: \[\theta = \tan^{-1}\left(\frac{F_y}{F_x}\right).\] This approach makes it possible to break complicated systems down into simple algebraic calculations and to predict the dynamics of the system precisely.

xy +q₁−q₂ q₀ F1 F2 Ftotal Fx Fy θ

How to read the lab

The glass table and the grid

All the charges are locked to the plane of the table (2D), even when you rotate the camera. Each grid cell is 0.1 m, and the X axis and Y axis are marked with bright lines that meet at the test charge.

The source charges

Red spheres for positive charges \((+)\) and blue spheres for negative charges \((-)\). The larger the charge, the larger the sphere and the stronger its halo. The label above each sphere is the size of the charge.

The test charge \(q_0\)

The white sphere at the center of the grid, \(q_0 = +1Q\), fixed at the origin. All the forces are calculated on it.

The laser beams: the force of each source

A thin flowing beam runs from each source to the test charge, and a thin arrow in the color of the source comes out of the test charge: the force \(\vec{F}_i\) according to Coulomb's law. For repulsion the arrow points away from the source, and for attraction it points in toward it.

The gold arrow: the resultant force

The thick arrow is the vector sum \(\vec{F}_{total} = \sum \vec{F}_i\). The length of every arrow is proportional to the magnitude of the force: one cell for every \(0.05\,\text{N}\). An arrow longer than 10 cells is cut at length 10.

The angle arc \(\theta\)

A gold arc between the X axis and the gold arrow: exactly the angle that the formula \(\theta = \tan^{-1}\left(\frac{F_y}{F_x}\right)\) calculates in the math panel. The angle is measured counterclockwise from the X axis.

√x²+y²

The transparent math panel

In the top right corner: the sum of the \(x\) components and the sum of the \(y\) components, the Pythagorean theorem and the angle, with the numbers of the system at this moment.

The Resolution Cam

The Resolution Cam button switches to a top view (Top-Down 2D). There, "Show components" splits every diagonal vector into two dashed arrows: the \(X\) component from the test charge, and the \(Y\) component from the tip of the \(X\) component.

Selecting, the slider and dragging

Clicking a charge selects it (a gold ring) and opens its slider in the control column, from \(-5Q\) to \(+5Q\). Dragging moves it across the table in steps of half a cell, and no closer than one cell to the test charge.

Learning scenarios

"The Magic of Symmetry" places five \(+Q\) charges on a semicircle around the test charge, and shows in an animation the \(Y\) components cancelling and the \(X\) components adding up.

Camera

Dragging on empty background rotates the camera through 360 degrees, the wheel zooms in and out, and dragging with the right button pans. In the top view the camera does not rotate.

Speed and pause

The speed slider only changes the pace of the animation (the pulsing, the flow of the beams and the symmetry scenario), and ⏸ freezes it. The forces themselves do not depend on time.

1 μC

Units

\(Q = 1\,\mu\text{C}\), one cell \(= 0.1\,\text{m}\) and \(\frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0} = 8.99\times 10^9\,\frac{\text{N}\cdot\text{m}^2}{\text{C}^2}\). So the force between \(+1Q\) and \(q_0\) at a distance of one cell is \(0.899\,\text{N}\).

To the lab ↓
Loading the lab...
Transparent math panel
1

Experiments to try in the lab

  1. The "tug of war" experiment (getting to know the directionality of vectors). Place one positive charge \((+Q)\) at some distance from the test charge. Now, place an exactly identical charge on the other side of the test charge. Finally, change the second charge to negative \((-Q)\) with the slider, and watch the change in the gold arrow (the resultant force).
    This experiment illustrates the deep foundation of vector addition. When the charges are positive and placed opposite each other, their laser beams push in exactly opposite directions, and the gold arrow collapses to zero. The system is in "equilibrium". But the moment one of them becomes negative, magic happens: instead of cancelling each other, the repulsive force from the positive charge and the attractive force toward the negative charge now act in the same direction. The gold arrow leaps and doubles its length. This is the eureka moment in which the student understands that a vector sum is not just "adding numbers", but depends entirely on direction.
  2. The "illusion of the half" experiment (testing the inverse-square law). Place a single charge on the X axis, at a distance of 2.5 cells from the test charge. Notice the length of the force vector. Now, drag the charge back so that it is exactly 5 cells away (double the distance).
    Here we reveal the secret of the "square of the distance" in Coulomb's law \(\left(\frac{1}{r^2}\right)\). Intuitively, the human brain expects that when we double the distance, the force will drop to half. However, in the simulation you will see in a smooth animation that the force vector shrinks not to a quarter of its original length! The experiment burns into memory the fact that the effect of distance on the electric force is dramatic, decays quickly, and is not a straight line (linear).
  3. The "diagonal force" experiment (resolving and adding in 2D). Place a positive charge \((+Q)\) exactly on the X axis, and another positive charge of the same strength \((+Q)\) at exactly the same distance on the Y axis. Turn on the "Resolution Cam" button and examine the transparent math panel.
    The experiment pulls the student out of one-dimensional thinking. You will see how two forces acting at 90 degrees to each other create a diagonal resultant force (at 45 degrees). The Resolution Cam will show visually that the Pythagorean theorem is not just a dry formula on the board: the laser beams of the components build a perfect right triangle before your eyes, with the gold arrow as its hypotenuse. This is how theoretical geometry turns into a tangible physical force.
  4. The "breaking the symmetry" experiment (superposition on a semicircle). Load the built-in "Magic of Symmetry" scenario (five positive charges arranged on a semicircle). Watch the animation of the Y components cancelling. Now, flip the sign of the two extreme charges (the top one and the bottom one) to negative, and watch the dramatic change in the resultant force.
    This experiment raises the level and demonstrates how to handle complex systems. In the original arrangement, as learned in class, the Y components of the extreme charges cancelled each other and only contributed to the push along the X axis. When they become negative, they suddenly pull instead of push. The student will see in real time how their X components change direction and offset the effect of the other charges, while the Y components still cancel. This exercise teaches a critical tool in physics: always look for the axes of symmetry, and understand that a small change of sign rewrites the whole equation.
  5. The "balance challenge" experiment (a point of equilibrium). Place a weak charge of \(+1Q\) at a distance of 1.5 cells from the test charge. Your goal is to bring the gold arrow at the center completely to zero (equilibrium), using a single additional charge that is four times stronger \((+4Q)\). Where will you have to place it to win the challenge?
    This experiment is the "boss test" that combines everything together. To balance the repulsion of a weak, nearby charge, we must place the strong, repelling charge on the other side of the test charge, but at what distance? Thanks to the understanding of Coulomb's equation gained in experiment 2, the student will discover (or calculate in the math panel) that to offset a factor of 4 in the strength of the charge, the charge only has to be moved 2 times farther away (since \(2^2 = 4\)).