LIMA
With God's help
עברית

Pulley System

The theory in brief

Analyzing a complex pulley system rests on two pillars: Newton's second law and kinematic constraint equations. First, you isolate each mass and write an independent force equation for it, of the form \(\Sigma F = ma\). The forces acting are usually the tension force of the string \((T)\) upward and the force of gravity \((mg)\) downward, so you get equations such as \(T - mg = ma\).

However, since there are more unknowns than force equations, you use the fact that the length of the string \((L)\) stays constant throughout the motion. You express the total length as the sum of the segments between the pulleys and the masses, and since the length is constant, its second derivative with respect to time equals zero \[\frac{d^2L}{dt^2} = 0.\] This mathematical step provides the kinematic constraint equation, which directly relates the accelerations of the different bodies (for example \(a_1 + a_2 = -a_3\)). Solving the system of force equations together with the kinematic constraint equation makes it possible to extract the exact acceleration of each mass separately, as well as the tensions in the strings.

A m₃ m₁ m₂ L₃Lp L₁L₂ AB L₃ + Lp = constL₁ + L₂ = const a₃ = −a₁ + a₂2

How to read the lab

Fixed pulley A

Attached to the ceiling. The green rope runs over it: \(m_3\) hangs on the left, the movable pulley on the right.

Movable pulley B

Hangs on the green rope and moves with it. The cyan rope runs over it, with \(m_1\) (left) and \(m_2\) (right) at its ends.

The green rope \((T_2)\)

The main rope. At the movable pulley it "splits" into the two cyan strings, and dots of light flow along it. Its thickness is always exactly twice the cyan thickness, because \(T_2 = 2T_1\).

The cyan strings \((T_1)\)

The thickness grows with the tension. When the tension drops to zero the rope turns into a thin dashed line: it is slack.

Gravity \((mg)\)

A red arrow pointing down from the center of each mass.

Tension \((T)\)

A blue arrow pointing up from the point where the rope is attached. Red and blue share the same scale, so you can see which one "wins".

Acceleration arrows \((a)\)

Solid yellow: the acceleration relative to the floor. Dashed orange \((a')\) next to \(m_1\) and \(m_2\): the acceleration relative to the movable pulley. Next to B, the arrow \(a_p\) shows the pulley's acceleration.

Motion blur trail

Ghost images of each mass at its previous positions. A longer trail means a higher speed.

Equation bubble (Live Data)

Hovering over a mass, or over the movable pulley, shows its force equation with the numbers of this moment.

Kinematics ruler (Show Kinematics)

The rope segments \(L_1, L_2, L_3, L_p\) are tagged, and in the column at the side their sum stays frozen at \(12.00\,\text{m}\). Pink dashed lines mark each mass's starting position and its \(\Delta y\).

Mass sliders

Change \(m_1, m_2, m_3\) between \(0\) and \(20\,\text{kg}\), even while the motion is running.

Play, Pause and Step

Play starts the motion from the starting position. ⏸ freezes time, and Step advances it by 0.04 seconds. The motion stops when a mass hits the floor or a pulley.

Simulation speed and the snail

The slider sets how many times real time the simulation runs. The snail button 🐌 slows time down to 10%.

To the lab ↓
Loading the lab...
1

Experiments to try in the lab

  1. The classic Atwood limit (neutralizing the movable pulley). On the control sliders, set the masses so that \(m_1 = 4\) kg and \(m_2 = 4\) kg. Set the upper mass to \(m_3 = 16\) kg. Run the simulation and examine the acceleration and tension arrows.
    When \(m_1\) and \(m_2\) are identical, they balance each other perfectly on the movable pulley. As a result, there is no relative motion between them, and the movable pulley together with the two masses behaves as one continuous block with a mass of 8 kg. The experiment shows how a complex system collapses into the simplest system – a classic Atwood machine – in which a 16 kg body pulls an 8 kg body. The cyan lines \((T_1)\) will keep the same, static length relative to the pulley, and only the green line \((T_2)\) will do the work against gravity.
  2. The relative-acceleration illusion (a falling elevator). Set the masses so that \(m_1 = 1\) kg, \(m_2 = 8\) kg and \(m_3 = 1\) kg. Turn on the "snail" button (slow motion) and pay close attention to the direction of the acceleration arrow of \(m_1\) relative to the floor, compared with its motion along its own rope.
    This is the "eureka" moment of understanding relative motion. On the one hand, \(m_1\) is very light compared with \(m_2\), so it is pulled violently upward along its cyan line toward the movable pulley. However, because \(m_3\) is too light to hold the system up, the movable pulley itself plunges downward with a tremendous acceleration. The end result? You will see \(m_1\) getting closer to the floor, even though it is "climbing" the rope. The experiment burns into your mind that the absolute acceleration of a body is the vector sum of its relative acceleration and the acceleration of its frame of reference.
  3. The free-fall anomaly (the weak link). Set \(m_3 = 8\) kg and \(m_1 = 8\) kg, and lower \(m_2\) to 0 kg (or to the lowest value the simulation allows). Run the simulation and focus on the tension in the green rope \((T_2)\) and on the acceleration of \(m_3\).
    This experiment reveals the nature of "tension" in physics. The moment \(m_2\) is set to zero, its rope cannot offer any resistance. Without resistance, the tension in the cyan rope \((T_1)\) collapses to zero at once. And since \(T_2 = 2T_1\) (as the rope thicknesses in the simulation show), the tension in the green rope vanishes completely as well! As a result, \(m_3\) enters a state of complete free fall \((a = g)\), as if the string had been cut, even though \(m_1\) is heavy and still attached to the system. Tension requires resistance at both ends; without it, the force simply evaporates.
  4. Dynamic equilibrium (hovering inside a storm). Your challenge: set \(m_1 = 4\) kg and \(m_2 = 12\) kg. Now try to find (by trial and error, or by calculation) the exact value of \(m_3\) that will make it stay hovering in the air without any motion at all \((a_3 = 0)\), while \(m_1\) and \(m_2\) move wildly.
    For \(m_3\) to stand still, the tension in the green rope \((T_2)\) must be exactly equal to its weight \((m_3g)\). This means that the dynamic system of \(m_1\) and \(m_2\), even though it accelerates and changes positions, has to produce a constant, specific tension that will hold \(m_3\) up. The experiment demonstrates in a mesmerizing way how the dynamic tension of an accelerating system is not equal to the sum of its static weights (you will find that the required \(m_3\) equals \(12\) kg, which is exactly \(\frac{4m_1m_2}{m_1+m_2}\), and not 16 kg as the mistaken intuition might suggest).
  5. The rope economy (proving the kinematic constraint). Turn on the "X-ray" feature (the kinematics ruler). Choose random masses and press Play. Stop the simulation (Pause) after exactly 0.8 seconds. Read from the ruler the distance \(m_3\) traveled \((\Delta y_3)\), and the distances \(m_1\) and \(m_2\) traveled \((\Delta y_1, \Delta y_2)\).
    The experiment translates the intimidating equation \(a_3 = -\frac{a_1 + a_2}{2}\) into tangible reality. When you measure the distances, you will see that every centimeter of rope that \(m_3\) "pulls" toward itself or releases is split exactly between the two sides of the movable pulley. The "rope economy" is a zero-sum game – the rope is neither stretched nor lost. The experiment turns the mathematics of the kinematic constraint into a visual understanding of conservation of length, so that in the exam, the student no longer memorizes an equation, but simply pictures the length of rope flowing between the masses.